Shore's Blog: Everyone is comparing TNA to WCW in 2001, but they are off by about 13 years


prowrestling.net
MEMBERSHIP INFO | LOG-IN | CONTACT US | SUBMIT NEWS | ABOUT US
Insider News • Live TV & PPV Coverage • Hitlists • Results • Blogs

HOME | WWE NEWS | TNA NEWS | MMA NEWS | ALL NEWS | TV & PPV | ARENA REPORTS | VIEWPOINTS | PRODUCT REVIEWS | AWARDS



Dot Net App
GOT AN IPHONE, IPAD, IPOD TOUCH, SAMSUNG GALAXY TAB, OR ANDROID PHONE?

THEN BE SURE TO DOWNLOAD OUR NEW FREE APP
(or SEARCH "pro wrestling" in App Store or Android Marketplace)

Dot Net Podcast
CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO DOT NET FREE PODCAST IN ITUNES OR CLICK HERE FOR LISTING OF LATEST SHOWS

Former Staff Blogs


Shore's Blog: Everyone is comparing TNA to WCW in 2001, but they are off by about 13 years
2013-09-06 12:15:47


By Chris Shore

As the recent wrestler cuts, bad press, and jumbled storylines continue to choke the life out of TNA in the eyes of many, comparisons are being made to WCW and 2001, when the company finally collapsed and was sold off in pieces to Vince McMahon. It is an understandable comparison. Many of the faces that have been inextricably linked with the fall of WCW are in TNA, most notably Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff, and there are a number of business moves that mirror WCW moves at the time.

But I think it is more likely that people are looking at the wrong end of WCW's life cycle. TNA is not like WCW in 2001, they are more like WCW 13 years earlier. In 1988, Ted Turner purchased Jim Crockett Promotions (JCP) and changed the name to WCW. If any comparisons are to be made to TNA and WCW, I think it is this period in WCW's history that is most like what we are seeing today.

Poor leadership: WCW's early days were plagued by poor leadership, just like TNA is today. WCW paraded a host of people in and out at the top of the company, some who knew nothing about wrestling, and others who had great experience, but were stuck in an old way of doing things that simply failed to build their audience.

TNA is no different. Dixie Carter continues to fumble around with her limited knowledge, and those she has hired to help seem ingrained to the WWE way of doing things. There's nothing wrong with what WWE does in the general, but the fact that TNA continues to try and be WWE shows they still don't understand their market. (And they are trying to be WWE, regardless of protests to the contrary.)

Great but misused talent: When Turner bought JCP in late 1988, the roster was full of great talent. Ric Flair, Sting, Lex Luger, and others led the card while names like "Mean" Mark Callous and "Stunning" Steve Austin were signed (and relegated to the mid-card) within a couple of years. Sting ended up in a feud with Robocop as his second (no lie). Luger feuded with "The Blackmailer." And Callous and Austin went on to have pretty good careers in another promotion. It's worth noting Flair (and others) had some good feuds in these early days, but the first few years of WCW are not known for using the talent as a whole correctly.

Compare that with TNA now. Bully Ray has a good story right now, but who else? AJ Styles had something, but that died a horrible death during his in-ring promo last week. The X Division is a joke. The tag division would be a joke but there aren't any actual tag teams in TNA, just random singles characters stuck together with zero logic behind the pairings. Most of the card is adrift in nothingness. Even the usually captivating Knockouts have lost their charm. This isn't a talent problem, it’s a management/creative problem. There's plenty of talent on the roster, just like WCW had, but they are being used poorly, just like WCW did.

Expanding too fast and a media giant purchase: As mentioned above, JCP was ultimately purchased by Ted Turner once the company was about to collapse under its own weight and debt. Crockett's money problems were many, but expanding too fast was one of the driving factors of the company's collapse. Turner, not wanting to see wrestling disappear from his channel, purchased the company for that reason.

It certainly looks like TNA may have expanded too soon. It pains me personally to say that because I was one of many voices calling for them to get out of the Impact Zone and take the show on the road. For whatever miniscule influence I have on the wrestling world, I feel bad about that now because while it has made TNA look better, it hasn't shown any increase in viewership while certainly adding a huge cost to the company. Lots of things are to blame for that, including the aforementioned terrible booking, but there is no question that the budget is much tighter than in the past and the biggest cost increase is in taking the show on the road.

Now TNA has not been bought by a media giant like WCW, but consider this: Viacom, which owns SpikeTV, bought Bellator and are seriously trying to make it a credible promotion. They have gone so far as to use their influence to get Bellator fighters to appear on TNA and be involved with the very top of the card. With all of that investment, would Viacom be willing to let TNA die off if the promotion reached that point? I don't believe they will. The relationship between Viacom and TNA is much more symbiotic than WWE's relationship with NBCU, and Viacom has a vested interest in making sure TNA does as well as possible. That may include purchasing the company should Panda Energy decide they have had enough.

Whether you think TNA is the WCW of 2001 or the WCW of 1988--or even some other struggling promotion from whatever year--there is no question that there are major problems in TNA. The lack of public information makes it difficult to pin down what the top problems are, but these are problems that are apparent just from watching the show each week. I am not predicting gloom and doom. After all, WCW of 1988 went on to become WCW of the mid-1990s that almost destroyed WWE. But there can be no question that TNA continues to struggle right now, and there are many who worry about the long-term health of the company because of it.

Questions? Comments? Anyone, anyone? Let me hear from you. Email me at css3238@gmail.com or tweet me @TheShoreSlant with whatever is on your mind.

And read my first work of fiction:
The Following Contest is a Dark Match available exclusively on ebook for all eReaders, smartphones, tablets, and PCs for only 99 cents.

RECOMMEND THIS ARTICLE:


READ OUR INSIDER NEWS BEFORE ANYONE ELSE! BECOME A MEMBER FOR JUST $7.50 A MONTH (or less with a year-long sub) - GET THE FIRST LOOK AT EXCLUSIVE INSIDER DOT NET NEWS, TONS OF EXCLUSIVE AUDIO CONTENT, MEMBER MESSAGE BOARD ACCESS, START YOUR OWN BLOG, AND VIEW THE SITE WITHOUT ANY ADVERTISING: SIGN ME UP (or MORE INFO)



RELATED ARTICLES FROM MGID AFFILIATE SITES...

From Around the Web


MEMBERSHIP INFO
Become a Dot Net Member right now for $7.50 a month or $66 a year ($5.50 a month avg.). Get exclusive audio, first-look insider news, Forum access, member blogs, more...

CLICK FOR SIGN-UP INFO


The Current Must-Read List
Gutteridge's WWE NXT Hit List: The Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic begins with Neville and Crowe vs. Gable and Jordan, and The Ascension vs. Rhyno and Corbin
Gleed's Blog: WWE is losing out on a ton of money with Rusev
WWE News: Jimmy Snuka removed from the WWE Hall of Fame page
9/2 Zim's WWE NXT TV review: The Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic kicks off with Neville & Solomon Crowe vs. Gable & Jordan and The Ascension vs. Rhyno and Baron Corbin, Apollo Crews in action, Alexa Bliss vs. Blue Pants and Eva Marie vs. Billie Kay, and appearances from Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa
9/2 Moore's TNA Impact Wrestling TV Review: EC3 vs. Matt Hardy for the TNA Title or Jeff Hardy's freedom on the line, GFW's Hostile Takeover, Bobby Lashley vs. Chris Mordetzky, Magnus's Feast or Fired contract is cashed in, PJ Black vs. Bobby Roode for the King of the Mountain Championship, and Kenny King vs. Bram
9/2 Powell's Ring of Honor TV Review: Jay Lethal vs. Hanson for the ROH TV Title, Jay Briscoe vs. Adam Page, Cedric Alexander vs. Caprice Coleman, and Cheeseburger vs. Bob Evans
09/02 Dot Net Weekly Audio Show Set List: Jimmy Snuka arrested on murder charge, Bram arrested, shooting at the WWE Performance Center, TNA's TV future, Hulk Hogan asks for forgiveness, WWE Night of Champions
9/1 WWE Smackdown TV spoilers: Full results of Thursday's television show (spoilers)
WWE News: Medical update on man shot at the WWE Performance Center
WWE statement on the arrest of Jimmy Snuka, still listed as a WWE Hall of Famer
ACCESS PREVIOUS MUST-READ ARTICLES

Vote In Our Latest Poll

WWE Raw Poll: Grade the August 31 episode
 
pollcode.com free polls
VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS
VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

Dot Net Free Podcasts
08/27 Prowrestling.net All Access Podcast - The Pretentious Pro Wrestling Podcast on the state of the WWE Divas Division, NXT Women's Division coming out of SummerSlam weekend
08/24 Prowrestling.net Podcast: Joel Gertner joines Jonny Fairplay to provide an in-perspective take on WWE SummerSlam weekend
08/24 Prowrestling.net Live Podcast: Special guest Justin Credible and Jason Powell take your phone calls the day after WWE SummerSlam
08/23 Prowrestling.net Live Podcast: Jason Powell and Zack Zimmerman take your phone calls on SummerSlam Sunday regarding the biggest show of the summer and NXT Takeover: Brooklyn
08/22 Prowrestling.net Not Exactly Live Podcast: Darren Gutteridge and Haydn Gleed talk WWE SummerSlam and completely ignore your phone calls
08/21 Prowrestling.net Live Podcast: Jason Powell and John Moore take your phone calls during the second of our of SummerSlam weekend shows
08/20 Prowrestling.net Live Podcast: Jason Powell and Will Pruett take your phone calls in the first our of SummerSlam weekend shows
08/19 Prowrestling.net Podcast: Triple H takes pro wrestling media questions and promotes Saturday's NXT Takeover: Brooklyn live special
08/18 Prowrestling.net All Access Podcast: WWE Raw audio review - In-person perspective on Brock Lesnar's homecoming, Dolph Ziggler's return, final hype for WWE SummerSlam, and more
08/08 Prowrestling.net All Access Podcast: Ultima Lucha Audio Review - Will Pruett and John Moore on Lucha Undergound's Season Finale!
CLICK FOR FULL LISTING OF ALL PODCASTS

Latest from Our Affiliate Site

_pwtorch.com_
CLICK HERE FOR MORE PWTORCH HEADLINES

© 2008-2012 LAST ROW MEDIA LLC • ALL RIGHTS RESERVED -- PRIVACY POLICY